So bought this for the first time and the pros:the price it was good compared to some other liquid eyeliners. Also I liked how easy it was to apply..it felt smove and I was able to get a really good precise line.The cons: it went on really black but when I looked in the mirror after 3 hours only of wear it had faded and I had only went to dinner plus it had come off in places and I couldn't understand as a. Not like a nightclub or something so hot and stuffy and b. 3 hours us nit a lot of time to expect something to say.It's possible it's premature as first use and like opening a fresh bottle of tomatoes sauce its almost like water first on first squeeze coming out so I will try again and then add an update and possibly change my thought on it.I would still recommend however for now. If it had longevity I would have give it a 5.